Three Seas Forum

the archives

dusted off in read-only


dharok Commoner | joined 14 June 2006 | 6 posts

Your Response To the PoN posted 14 June 2006 in General AnnouncementsYour Response To the PoN by dharok, Commoner

The PoN immersed me into a fantasy world full of complex relationships, realistic political associations, and credible motivations. It seemed that no character was introduced ex-nihilo, but rather each was placed within a web of duties and obligations to both their pasts and to their peers. The development of the characters as persons, their struggles with their own motivations and aspirations, and their individual struggles to either fulfill or actively ignore self-awareness, makes the world of PoN a rich environment, raising the narrative above a mere chronicle of events. view post

Who is most offensive. posted 19 June 2006 in Literature DiscussionWho is most offensive. by dharok, Commoner

Quote: "Virus":1smcxoi6
I agree, those find PON offensive would be of mose use as cannon fodder.[/quote:1smcxoi6]
I disagree with you: rape should always be offensive. But that's the point of putting such things into fiction: elements in the story are meant to offend and that is part of the aesthetic experience. view post

Needing some good suggestions. posted 20 June 2006 in Literature DiscussionNeeding some good suggestions. by dharok, Commoner

other than what has been mentioned already:

Oath of the Empire series by Thomas Harlan (showed promise, but it seemed to get away from him for some reason)

The Name of the Rose by Umberto Eco. It's not fantasy, but it is a great novel. view post

The Prologue posted 06 July 2006 in The Darkness That Comes BeforeThe Prologue by dharok, Commoner

I have started to re-read the three books from the series that are currently available, and I am ashamed to admit that I remember little of the Prologue from TDTCB.

What I am wondering about is with regards to the mounted rider who ends up fighting with Kellhus as he is running from the sranc. When Kellhus escapes the fight, he is threatened- by the rider whom he assumes is a nonman- that he will not be forgotten. Makes me wonder . . . IMO, this has not yet become significant, or am I missing something really obvious?

Also, the identity of the rider is really up for question. Ideas? view post

The Prologue posted 07 July 2006 in The Darkness That Comes BeforeThe Prologue by dharok, Commoner

interesting. . . I guess I need to pay more attention. view post

Esmet's betrayl, Bakker's massogeny, and a criticism posted 25 July 2006 in The Warrior ProphetEsmet's betrayl, Bakker's massogeny, and a criticism by dharok, Commoner

Quote: "butlersr":68hrg5ca
I think that to understand Esmett's betrayl one must see Esmi as Bakker's critique of women.[/quote:68hrg5ca]

I think you have been too quick to generalize. You might in fact be correct, but I see no reason to abstract Bakker's understanding of women from Esmett in order to apply it to all women. I think that first and foremost, it must be remembered that Bakker has written a work of fiction; not a philosophical treatise. view post


The Three Seas Forum archives are hosted and maintained courtesy of Jack Brown